Scientific vs. Public Attention: A comparison of Top Cited Papers in WoS and Top Papers by Altmetric Score
preprintposted on 03.02.2018, 09:55 by Sumit Kumar Banshal, aparna basu, Vivek kumar singh, Pranab Kumar Muhuri
Alternative metrics or altmetrics are article level metrics that have been used to quantify the attention given to scholarly papers in online fora or social media. In some way it was sought to replace journal level metrics such as the Impact Factor and also to see if early altmetric scores could predict highly cited papers. Early studies, done soon after altmetrics was suggested in 2013, were somewhat prem-ature as the use of social media was not widely prevalent, and their results may no longer be relevant at the present time when use levels have risen significantly. In the past year, 2016, Altmetric.com has tracked over 17 million mentions of 2.7 million different research outputs. Of these, the top 100 most-discussed journal articles of 2016 were presented with details of journals in which the research was published, affiliations of authors, fields, countries, etc. ..Our attempt is to obtain a bibliometric profile of these papers with high altmetric scores, to see the underly-ing patterns and characteristics that motivate high public attention. In parallel we have analyzed top 100 highly cited papers from the same year. Our objective in this empirical study is to examine the similarities and distinguishing features of scientific attention as measured by citations and public attention in online fora.