Sequential monitoring of cancer immunotherapy trial with random delayed treatment effect

Cancer immunotherapy trials are frequently characterized by a delayed treatment effect that violates the proportional hazards assumption. The log-rank test (LRT) suffers a substantial loss of statistical power under the nonproportional hazards model. Various group sequential designs using weighted LRTs (WLRTs) have been proposed under the fixed delayed treatment effect model. However, patients enrolled in immunotherapy trials are often heterogeneous, and the duration of the delayed treatment effect is a random variable. Therefore, we propose group sequential designs under the random delayed effect model using the random delayed distribution WLRT. The proposed group sequential designs are developed for monitoring the efficacy of the trial using the method of Lan-DeMets alpha-spending function with O’Brien-Fleming stopping boundaries or a gamma family alpha-spending function. The maximum sample size for the group sequential design is obtained by multiplying an inflation factor with the sample size for the fixed sample design. Simulations are conducted to study the operating characteristics of the proposed group sequential designs. The robustness of the proposed group sequential designs for misspecifying random delay time distribution and domain is studied via simulations.