The Persistence of the Hostile Environment after the Windrush Scandal

Unlike most immigration policy areas amidst Brexit, the government’s “hostile environment” approach has changed little since 2014, despite it making no measurable impact on the migration statistics the government prioritises while landing it in hot water over the Windrush Scandal. Why does the hostile environment nevertheless persist? Despite its strong association with today’s Conservatives, the hostile environment extends a decades-long trend of deepening various social systems’ involvement in UK immigration control, creating increasing problems when long-settled immigrants face suspicion at vulnerable life stages. Yet, the hostile environment provides a way to pursue legitimacy in immigration control given the UK state’s particular limitations and pressures: to demonstrate action against “illegal immigration,” avoid revealing earlier control lapses, and avert difficult reforms to more thoroughly monitor the population, like national ID cards. The risks of this approach have only increased as Brexit has unsettled migration statuses, yet the hostile environment will likely remain.