figshare
Browse
fjds_a_1324148_sm4253.docx (46.41 kB)

Supporting Impact with Evidence: A Content Analysis of Project Completion Reports

Download (46.41 kB)
journal contribution
posted on 2017-06-13, 16:44 authored by Bia Carneiro, Alessandra Garbero

Project Completion Reports (PCRs) are used by development institutions to tell a project’s story – achievements, failures, and learning. As such, they should provide evidence of effectiveness in bringing about development. But is this the case? Descriptive content analysis was applied to assess the extent of evidentiary support presented in the International Fund for Agricultural Development's end of project documentation, employing a custom conceptual framework to classify claims about project results found in PCRs based on results level, tone, evidence sources, and themes. Findings show the majority of claims relate to output or outcome level results and are positive, though not explicitly supported by evidence. The lack of evidence-based reporting carries implications to the objective measurement of development effectiveness.

Funding

This work was supported by the International Fund for Agricultural Development.

History